Could the allies have defeated russia

Operation unthinkable was the name given to two related but unrealised plans by the western. If world war 2 had involved only russia and germany, with no america, britain and allies involved, could russia have won. Im very sure the sov remnant would still be in siberia like a constant thorn in the nazi side. Could the allies have beaten germany in ww2 without soviet union. Apr 06, 2018 a war of defense in the west, from the beginning, would have benefited germany more than the allies. A department of defense official has backed the rand corporation think tanks claim that the russian military could defeat nato forces. This is because us and allies military was as big as the russians in 1945, the allies had complete command of the seas, the us still had unlimited reserves of man power not even used yet while the soviets had no more reserves, and would have the huge. How nazi germany could have crushed russia during world. Russia operated a small furtrade operations in alaska, coupled with missionaries to the natives.

In such a scenario, the united states and its allies. Dont forget how the soviet union saved the world from hitler the. Twothirds of russians 63 percent said the soviet red army would have overwhelmed germanys troops regardless of the actions of the u. What would have happened if the us had attacked the ussr in.

Also, germany would have needed to go into a total war economy from the outset, why they didnt do that i have no idea. Could the ussr have defeated nazi germany without the help of. If japan had attacked the ussr, would germany have defeated. Imagine no supplies reading the soviet union via the arctic convey. The war in the east between those 2 powers was the pinwheel on which the victor would emerge. An article in the times newspaper over the weekend reported that a majority of russians think that their country could have defeated germany in world war 2 without any help from the western allies.

Yes, it could have however it would have cost the germans dearly. Or with japans help might have taken all, but that means no us involvement. This is not a political video or alternate history. The soviet union is referred to as russia throughout the document. Most russians believe the soviet military would have been able to win world war ii without the efforts of the u. If the united states fights, then germany, france, poland and the united kingdom will follow. Could the allies have beaten germany in ww2 without soviet. Why america was indispensable to the allies winning world.

The majority of any offensive operation would have been undertaken by. The allies destroyed 176, said georgy kumanyov, a leading russian historian. What would have happened if russia was defeated in ww2. They only existed later because the russians had heavy tanks and formidable medium ones. Rest of russia, doubtful, and prob could have been separated. Nazi germany could have defeated the allies on technology and. I have been pondering this question for some time, and we have gone backandforth on this board an uncountable number of times about it.

Why the soviet union could not have won world war 2 without. Could the soviet union have defeated nazi germany without the help of the western allies. Could germany have ever defeated the russia in ww2. How nazi germany could have crushed russia during world war ii by david t. Which might very well have been alone at that point. Could nazi germany have defeated soviet russia under. Without the invasion of the ussr and the encounters with tanks like. Oct 08, 2009 i have been pondering this question for some time, and we have gone backandforth on this board an uncountable number of times about it. By defeat im imagining just getting to moscow and stopping. In addition, their military would have gotten stronger in 19411945 instead of getting ground down in russia.

Could the soviet union have defeated nazi germany without. In retrospect, would it have been better for the allies in. The soviet union could have defeated nazi germany on its own, but it would have taken it a lot longer and at much greater price and, of course, it would have taken the country much. I think the only way the allies could have taken out russia would have been to ally with the germans before the wehrmacht was ground to nothing.

With that in mind the germans could have easily defeated russia if germany had attacked russia first, instead of attacking france. In most conventional scenarios, even the european allies alone would give nato a tremendous medium term advantage over the russians. Russian victory day would the ussr have beaten hitler without us. Bombing russia must have seemed easier than confronting the german army on the battlefield. So without trying to speculate on what ifs, i think it can be conclusively said that the soviet army was a hell of a lot faster and more robust with the aid of the western allies, but with nazi germany was still tied up on 2 fronts fighting the western allies at the same time, the soviets would still have recaptured everything they lost in. So as soon as the battle of britain stalemated, he responded with his planned operation barbarossa, the invasion of russia over a thousand mile front, with 3 million men and more than 3000. The reason being that nazi germany lost the war in mid 43 after kursk before american industry arrived in the ussr they arrived later that year.

Most russians say they believe the red army would have defeated hitler without western assistance, levadas research shows. More likely than not, this would have required a successful assassination of hitler and almost complete capitulation by the remaining german brass. Russia had and still has huge amounts of natural resources. Would the allies have defeated the axis in wwii without the. It fought the lionshare of the german army, and her european allies, for the majority of the conflict while the western allies usually faced significantly smaller numbers of axis forces in europe. This is applying the rules of allies and axis slightly edited enjoy. Twentyseven percent answered that in their opinion the red army would have been defeated without the allies aid. Why the soviet union could not have won world war 2 without the western allies the soviet union unequivocally did the most of any power to defeat nazi germany during the second world war. The institute of modern russia continues its series of articles by alexander yanov on the history of russian nationalism. Oct 12, 2003 in this scenario both germany and japan have been defeated. Soviet union could have won wwii alone historian rt. If russia started world war iii, heres how it would go down. A war of defense in the west, from the beginning, would have benefited germany more than the allies.

What role did russia play during this second world war. Could germany have defeated russia in world war 2 answers. What would have happened if the allies invaded russia right after. Flying from allied bases in iran and syria, as well as neutral but antisoviet turkey, more than a hundred british and french bombers would continuously attack soviet oil fields in the caucuses in a night strategic bombing. The soviet union unequivocally did the most of any power to defeat nazi germany during the second world war. What would have happened if the us had attacked the ussr in 1945. Could the soviet union have beaten the us and her allies in. If the germans could inflict a decisive defeat on the soviets during this time, then perhaps the ussr could have negotiated a peace, as they would need time to rebuild.

Nearly two years of extensive wargaming and analysis shows that if russia were to conduct a shortwarning attack against the baltic states, moscows forces could roll to the outskirts of the estonian capital of tallinn and the latvian capital of riga in 36 to 60 hours. They lost millions of men and thousands of tanks and planes which could have been deployed in europe. A department of defense official has backed the rand corporation think tanks claim. In addition, their military would have gotten stronger in. Insiders are wrong, nato could beat russia defense one. Russia had been hammered pretty badly and while they had a huge army in the field they relied heavily on allied supplies to keep going. The hypothetical date for the start of the allied invasion of soviet held europe. Germany, japan, italy, and the soviet union could not build a successful fourengine heavy bomber. How could the germans have defeated the soviet union in. The allies beat germany in wwi despite the germans defeating the russians in that war. Could germany have defeted the allies in ww1 answers. Nov 11, 20 the institute of modern russia continues its series of articles by alexander yanov on the history of russian nationalism.

So if they were still alive and well what would have happened do you think. Russian soldiers are pictured next to the reichstag building in this. Jun 14, 2016 could russia really take down nato in just a couple of days. My guess is the allies could have defeated russia if they committed to an allout war essentially keep up the pace they had through most of wwii. They saved the world and its civilisation and at the time there was no force other than the soviets that could have defeated the nazis. How japan could have won world war ii while london and paris dithered over whether to ally with the communists, berlin had no such hesitation. Feb 08, 2009 russia had and still has huge amounts of natural resources. Had they been allowed to do so, it is possible that they could have held ground, reinforced in the spring, and finished the soviets off. Germany could have defeated ussr in ww ii realclearhistory. What if the germans never attacked russia could the britishamericans have defeated the mighty german armies. Russias military is a shadow of its cold war self, but washington pundits sound as alarmist as always.

Could russia really take down nato in just a couple of days. I dont think a traditional invasion would have worked. Patton vs zhukov, usa vs ussr after 1945, who would have won. Imagine no supplies reading the soviet union via the arctic convey routes or iran. The germans would have to have periodic millitary offensives over the ural to try to destroy the last bits of soviet power.

One of the classic what ifs of the second world war centers on howor ifthe german invasion of the soviet union in june 1941, codenamed operation barbarossa, could have achieved a quick victory. As you know, we will be arguing about if nazi germany could have defeated the allies with technology and strategy alone. The only way to do this would be to get rid of stalin. But if it could be done, and the american public could be convinced that going to war against the ussr was a good idea, then the us and her allies would have steamrolled the soviets all the way back to their prewar borders, if not beyond. Even with the long russian supply lines and the loss of usa lend lease support, a long slog towards russia. Germany could have defeated the soviet union, but in only by instigating a general collapse of the soviet political superstructure. The soviet union in its otl form could not have won. What would have happened if the us had attacked the ussr. In june 1941 the germans launched operation barbarossa.

The soviet union alone indeed could have won world war ii, but would have done it at a much slower pace, believes british historian professor geoffrey roberts. Just consider there is a big straight railroad that crosses all inhabitated siberia, granting for supply and reinforcements from manchuria. That problem worked both ways though as there was only so many personnel that could be stationed on malta due to supply capability. Defeat of germany in world war ii was possible without u. Aug 06, 2011 in the end, the soviet union by itself could have defeated nazi germany over a period of time, whether the allies ever became involved or not.

No i dont think the soviets would have won, most likely in a war they would have been driven out of eastern europe and back into russia. How germany and japan couldve won realclearhistory. Dec 16, 2018 we all know that germans turned on soviet union and invaded it in 1941. In this installment, the author explores the reason for the 1917 revolution and concludes that the bolsheviks did not win the battle for power.

Spoiled from their easy victories over poland, france and the rest of europe, the germans to win this war would have had to commit to it fully prior to the start in 1941. America, in contrast, produced 34,000 excellent b17s, b24s, and b29s. Russia might take parts of the baltics, but it would suffer heavily under nato airpower. From there, working with the americans, the allies could have planned for an invasion of africa, which in turn could have led to further incursions in italy and the balkans. In this scenario both germany and japan have been defeated. Jan 14, 2017 why the soviet union could not have won world war 2 without the western allies the soviet union unequivocally did the most of any power to defeat nazi germany during the second world war.

Had germany won battle of stalingrad in 1942, they would have likely defeated russia and proceed to attack the western countries, including u. The western allies have already begun their post wwii force reductions. She could have defeated russia in one or two years, possibly avoided goading britain into the war, and then turned her attention to france. If he defeated russia, the best case scenario would have been the stalemate. Yes, france was out of the game, from an allied perspective, but american industrial dominance was even greater. Aug 15, 2019 bombing russia must have seemed easier than confronting the german army on the battlefield. Once it became clear that russia could not be destroyed by the onset of winter, hitler also demanded that the wehrmacht not fall back and take defensive positions. Could germany have defeated the soviet union economically.

Of course, had britain and france not still been at war with germany, it is unlikely that italy would have invaded greece in 19401941 and risked a british declaration of war so in that case. It must be remembered that the western allies, mainly france and. The best source for an answer to this may be a british study of a joint usbritish war with the soviet union worked up in may june 1945. Could the ussr have defeated nazi germany without the help. Its hard to imagine how germany could have been defeated if they hadnt invaded russia. How nazi germany could have crushed russia during world war. By 1861 the project lost money, threatened to antagonize the americans, and could not be defended from britain. In the end, the soviet union by itself could have defeated nazi germany over a period of time, whether the allies ever became involved or not. We all know that germans turned on soviet union and invaded it in 1941. This will make the war a different scenario but lets see where this all goes. It would have come down to who had the better capacity to resupply their forces, the axis had the shorter more. Russians say the soviet army could have beaten the. Feb 02, 2015 no i dont think the soviets would have won, most likely in a war they would have been driven out of eastern europe and back into russia. Finally, it is true that without russian manpower, the us and the rest of the allies could not have defeated germany.

Id say that if we still got to supply the ussr with material, then the ussr could have defeated germany and its allies on its own. Capturing moscow in 1941 might have negatively affected the germans. The germans hoped that if they could eliminate the su before the us participated officially on the war, britain would give up. The soviet union suffered the most casualties in the conflict, and the issue is highly emotional for many russians. An event like the berlin blockade triggers off a war.

Could russia alone have defeated germany in world war 2. Germany was furious about it and wanted to get revenge. Most historians agree than the turning point that caused germany to lose ww2 was invading russia. True, america had to fight two wars, but i still think that they could have defeated the germans. Not only did this mean that, after dday, germany would be. Once hes gone, i think theres a good chance the whole edifice comes crumbling down. At the same time, 67 percent of respondents said they were sure that the soviet people could have repelled the nazi aggression without any outside help. This is the fourth in a series of five articles providing critical analysis as to how germany might. Red army could have defeated nazis without allies, most. For one, hitler could have delayed his attack on russia until 1942 or. It would have come down to who had the better capacity to resupply their forces, the axis had the shorter more protected lines while the allies had the greater capacity. Mark grimsley o ne of the classic what ifs of the second world war centers on howor ifthe german invasion of the soviet union in june 1941, codenamed operation barbarossa, could have achieved a quick victory. Apart from the usa, all the other combatants economies are in taters.